- A TechNote on Wireless and Mobility
- Michael Finneran, President
- dBrn Associates
The one session on Wi-Fi that stood out was "Wi-Fi: Gigabit Performance (and a lot more!)." It provided an overview of the emerging 8023.11ac and ad radio links, along with other interesting developments. The CEO of the Wi-Fi Alliance, Edgar Figueroa moderated the panel. It featured the Director for Standards and Business Development at Realtek, Sean Coffey talking about 802.11ac. The Marketing VP at Wilocity, Mark Grodzinksy discussed developments with 802.11ad. We'll look at 802.11ac in this TechNote and 802.11ad in the next.
What Network Managers Need to Know
Lisa Phifer of Core Competence wrote about 802.11ac and ad back in March, but Sean Coffey of Realtek got into the details at Interop. The new standard will be the follow-on to 802.11n and will operate exclusively in the 5 GHz band delivering data rates into the gigabit range. At the raw bit level, 802.11ac will support data rates from 6.5 Mbps to 866.7 Mbps on a single stream using a combination of wider bandwidth channels and more efficient coding mechanisms.
Where 802.11n could run on 20 MHz or 40 MHz channels, 802.11ac can be deployed on 20-, 40-, 80-, and 160-MHz channels. Bigger channels translate into more potential bits per second, but it also means there will be fewer channels available. That's something network managers will have to take into account in their planning.
To pack more bits into the available radio spectrum, 802.11ac also uses a more efficient coding system. Like 802.11a, g, and n, 802.11ac uses OFDM signal encoding. However, where 802.11a, g, and n maxed out at 64-QAM (six-bits per symbol), the 802.11ac defines modulation up to 256-QAM (eight-bits per symbol), a 33% increase in efficiency. As we try to send more bits per cycle of radio bandwidth, the probability of error increases. So some of those bits are used to provide forward error correction to improve the reliability of the transmission.
More On MIMO
802.11ac also adds important enhancements to the multiple input-multiple output (MIMO) capability. MIMO allows a transmitter to send multiple simultaneous data streams over the same radio channel and it was first included in the 802.11n standard. However, where 80.11n can send up to four-streams (most existing products use a max of two or three), 802.11ac can go to eight-streams. Eight streams at 866.7 Mbps adds up to a total maximum data rate of 6.934 Gbps versus a maximum of 600 Mbps for 802.11n. In other words, we're looking at a 10x increase in capacity.
The high capacity per stream will be very important to devices like smartphones. The downside of running multiple data streams is that it calls for multiple radios. That means more power draw. To conserve battery, devices like smartphones generally use a single stream, but now that stream will be able to carry a data rate of 866.7 Mbps versus 150 Mbps in 802.11n.
The other key feature in 802.11ac is multi-user MIMO capability. In the 802.11n MIMO implementation, all the streams are used to communicate between the access point and a single device. With multi-user MIMO, different MIMO streams could be directed to different users. This could provide a real boost in an environment where the access point has multiple radios, but the devices are single stream. The access point could now be communicating with multiple users simultaneously, greatly increasing the total network throughput.
While the standard has not yet been finalized, chipsets for 802.11ac are already going into production and we can expect to see enterprise products rolling out early next year. While users are typically reluctant to purchase "pre-standard" implementations, the Wi-Fi Alliance's track record in ensuring compliance with the eventual standard is without blemish, so we fully expect that the lack of an official standard will not deter sales. That's the scenario we saw with 802.11n.
Conclusion
Interoperability has been a challenge in many parts of our industry, but the Wi-Fi Alliance has managed to get all of the key vendors working out of the same playbook, which is a big reason Wi-Fi continues to flourish. Mr. Figueroa's statistics are pretty impressive. 1.2 billion Wi-Fi devices were shipped in 2011 and the technology has seen 10% year-over-year growth every year since 2001,
Suffice it to say that Wi-Fi is not going away any time soon, and the work of the Wi-Fi Alliance in ensuring multi-vendor interoperability has been one of the keys to its enormous success.
Suppose a company is only half-way through an upgrade to 802.11n. Is support for 802.11ac going to be a hardware (a.k.a. forklift) or a software upgrade?
Unfortunately, it's hardware. Equally unfortunate is the fact that with the advantage 802.11ac brings to Wi-Fi on smartphones, you can expect it to show up in a big hurry- the pundits are saying sales may equal 802.11n by 2015 and eliminate it by 2018. That assumption is based on the normal two-year replacement cycle for smartphones. I'd get with my vendor to talk about a strategy, but that may involve slowing down your 802.11n rollout and waiting for the 802.11ac. Vendors don't like to hear about deferring a purchase, so you might do well to seek out advice from someone who doesn't have a vested interest in a particular outcome.
Although upgrade involves hardware, it's not necessarily a forklift upgrade. From a technology standpoint, with the exception of MU-MIMO, 11ac is more of an incremental upgrade than replacement for 11n.
One sensible strategy to move an 11n deployment towards 11ac might be to position 11n APs in locations where they meet design specs for 5GHz coverage and capacity. If you haven't already, start pushing clients towards 5GHz to largely deprecate use of 2.4GHz where possible. These two moves will leave you well-positioned to deploy 11ac APs as a drop-in-replacement for 11n APs when your WLAN utilization reaches the point where 11ac is needed.
Another (complementary) strategy is to look carefully at your WLAN infrastructure vendor's migration path to 11ac. Some enterprise AP vendors are already offering pre-purchase discounts, trade-in coupons towards 11ac APs, and modular platforms that allow 11n radios to swapped out for 11n radios (or added to an array). Taking advantage of these offers can protect investment in 11n APs that you plan to use for awhile.
Also, think about where/how you can tap the advantages of 11ac. For example, you may only need those high data rates for video in selected areas, but do fine with 11n for a long time elsewhere. You may only really need higher-density coverage in public spaces, but be fine with lln in many offices. And so forth. So think about 11ac deployment in terms of gradual enhancement of your existing WLAN and look at your existing infrastructure to determine impacts of adding 11ac APs where and as-needed.